Home / FAQ

Collector FAQ

Last updated Nov 20, 2026. Educational only; we don't authenticate items or rate authenticators.

Common questions

What's the fastest way to check a COA?

Find who issued it, then enter the certificate or hologram number on that issuer's own website, not a link from the listing. Compare the returned record's signer, item and photo with the item itself. PSA warns that a matching number alone doesn't eliminate risk, since real numbers get copied.

Sources: psacard.com · ebay.com

Does a COA guarantee an autograph is authentic?

No. A COA is a document stating someone's opinion or record, and it's only as valuable as the reputation of whoever issued it, according to eBay. The FBI's Operation Bullpen found forgers commonly used COAs to make fake signatures look genuine. Check the issuer, run its lookup, and compare the record.

Sources: ebay.com · philliphalpern.com

PSA vs JSA vs Beckett: what's the difference?

All three are third-party authenticators that examine existing signatures and issue numbered certifications, each with its own online lookup: PSA at psacard.com/cert, JSA at spenceloa.com, and Beckett BAS at bas.beckett.com/verify-certificate. As of Oct 12, 2026, none appeared on eBay's list of disallowed COA issuers. We don't rank authenticators.

Sources: psacard.com · psacard.com · spenceloa.com · beckett-authentication.com · bas.beckett.com · ebay.com

What's the difference between a witnessed and an authenticated autograph?

In witnessed programs, such as Upper Deck, TRISTAR and MLB, a representative watches the signing and applies a numbered hologram. With third-party authentication, such as PSA/DNA or Beckett, an outside company examines an existing signature, compares it with exemplars, and gives an opinion with a tamper-evident label.

Sources: upperdeck.com · tristarauthentic.com · mlb.com · psacard.com · beckett-authentication.com

Is a seller-issued COA worth anything?

It depends entirely on the seller's reputation. eBay says a COA is only as valuable as whoever issued it, and lists some issuers whose COAs it doesn't allow. The FBI's Operation Bullpen found forgers often supplied their own COAs, so treat a seller's certificate as a claim to check, not proof.

Sources: ebay.com · philliphalpern.com

What should I do if an authenticator's lookup is down?

Keep the full cert number and ask the seller for clear photos of the label, sticker or COA. An unavailable lookup neither confirms nor rules out authenticity. For high-value items, consider waiting until the lookup returns, then check it and save a dated screenshot. Our home page tracks lookup status.

Sources: cardgrade.io · rippingpatrol.com · walkouts.com

What is the Beckett BAS lookup URL?

Beckett BAS autograph certificates are checked at bas.beckett.com/verify-certificate, linked from Beckett's Autographs page. Beckett graded cards (BGS) use beckett.com/grading/card-lookup. Use those official addresses rather than links in listings, and save a dated screenshot of the result showing the cert number and details returned.

Sources: bas.beckett.com · beckett.com · walkouts.com

What if the lookup returns no record?

A missing record isn't automatically a bad sign. Upper Deck says items from before 2002 and many show-signed items aren't in its online database, and JSA has said new certifications can take weeks to post. Contact the issuer directly with the number and photos before drawing conclusions.

Sources: upperdeck.com · yelp.com

Does a matching cert number prove my item is genuine?

Not on its own. PSA notes that verifying a number "does not eliminate risk", because counterfeiters sometimes copy real certification numbers from public sources. Compare the record's photo, signer and item description with the item you have, and buy from sellers who show the label and number clearly.

Sources: psacard.com

Which COAs does eBay not allow?

eBay publishes a list of people and organizations whose COAs and LOAs are not allowed in autographed-item listings, on its autographed items and COA policy page. Being absent from that list isn't an endorsement. eBay says a COA is only as valuable as the reputation of its issuer.

Sources: ebay.com

Does COA Guide authenticate autographs?

No. COA Guide is an educational reference about who issues autograph certificates. We don't examine items, give opinions on signatures, rate authenticators, or say whether any item or seller is genuine. Every factual statement on the site links to a public source so you can check it yourself.

Sources: coaguide.com

More detail: How to verify a COA · Authenticator directory · Methods