Home / Flags & Fakes / Issue #6

Issue #6 · Nov 12, 2026

Flags & Fakes #6: Fake PSA label kits, loose real labels, and more stolen PSA certs

Welcome back to Flags & Fakes, the free weekly from COA Guide. We collect public, sourced information about autograph authenticators and Certificates of Authenticity. We don't authenticate items. Every claim below links to its source.

A real cert number, the wrong card

On November 8, CheckCOA wrote up two finds Japanese collectors posted on X. One was online listings for do-it-yourself PSA-style labels and empty cases, printed with certificate numbers that belong to real cards PSA graded. The other was a sold bundle of genuine PSA and BGS labels taken out of their cases, including PSA 10 and BGS 10 labels (CheckCOA).

Both are built to pass the usual check: type the number into the grader's lookup and you get a real record. In one example CheckCOA describes, the copied number still returns an active GEM MT 10 record at PSA. CheckCOA added the eleven numbers it could read to its database, marking the loose genuine labels as "Suspected" rather than fake (CheckCOA). The examples are trading cards, but the lesson carries over to slabbed autographs.

PSA found more parcels from the October 13 theft

In a November 10 editor's note, PSA said its audit of shipment records turned up additional parcels taken in the October 13 FedEx truck theft in Santa Ana. It has deactivated those certificates too, is working with marketplaces to watch for them, and says it will share more cert numbers as the investigation allows (PSA). That's on top of the 6,451 items PSA listed in October.

75 fake Super Bowl rings stopped at customs

U.S. Customs and Border Protection said on November 5 that officers at Houston's Bush Intercontinental Airport seized 75 counterfeit Kansas City Chiefs Super Bowl rings. The parcel arrived October 30 from Guangzhou, China, labeled "Hair Pins Metal," and the NFL confirmed the rings were fake (CBP).

Lookup status this week

A quiet week. Every daily check from Nov 5 through Nov 12, 2026, 6:39 AM PT gave the same result (live tracker):

  • Responding: JSA, Upper Deck, MLB, Tristar, ACOA, SWAU, GOAT Authentics, Celebrity Authentics
  • Check blocked: Beckett, PSA and Fanatics (bot protection; not an outage signal)
  • Erroring: OnlineAuthentics, still returning an HTTP 500 server error, as it has since Oct 28

This week's verification tip

Match the card, not just the number. A lookup describes the certificate, not necessarily the slab in front of you. Where the grader has photos for that cert, compare centering, print lines and wear with the item in the case. Ask for clear photos of both sides, and treat recently re-cased high-grade slabs as unverified until they match (CheckCOA). Official lookups are on our PSA/DNA page, and the full checklist is in How to verify a COA.


Spotted an error? Reply or email hello@coaguide.com. Our corrections process is on the methods page.

We don't authenticate items. Educational info with sources only.

Get Flags & Fakes by email

Subscribe on Beehiiv

Free weekly email. Unsubscribe anytime.

← Issue #5 Issue #7 →