Welcome back to Flags & Fakes, the free weekly from COA Guide. We collect public, sourced information about autograph authenticators and Certificates of Authenticity. We don't authenticate items. Every claim below links to its source.
Fakes are copying PSA's newer letter design
On October 27, the collector-run registry CheckCOA wrote that it had found, for the first time, counterfeit PSA Letters of Authenticity copying PSA's newer red-header format, paired with signed jerseys (CheckCOA). Those are CheckCOA's findings, not ours. The takeaway is general: a familiar letter design proves nothing on its own.
The useful check: PSA's FAQ says an LOA includes an image of the exact item PSA examined, viewable through cert verification (CheckCOA, citing PSA's FAQ). Run the number on PSA's own site and compare the item to PSA's photo, not the photo printed on the letter. If there's no image to compare, CheckCOA's advice is to get new certification before buying. Our PSA/DNA page has the official lookup.
PSA reopens a cheaper grading tier
PSA announced on October 28 that its new Value service opens October 29 at $39.99 in the U.S. ($500 max insured value), with an estimated 90 to 100 business days. Standard and Priority estimates each drop by 20 days, to 70–80 and 50–60 business days (PSA). PSA says its backlog is currently 7.2 million items (PSA). This is card grading, not autograph authentication, but it matters if you've been holding cards back.
Lookup status this week
Our automated check ran Oct 29, 2026, 6:40 AM PT (live tracker):
- Responding: JSA, Upper Deck, MLB, Tristar, ACOA, SWAU, GOAT Authentics, Celebrity Authentics
- Check blocked: Beckett, PSA and Fanatics (bot protection; not an outage signal)
- Erroring: OnlineAuthentics. It went from no response to an HTTP 500 server error on Oct 28. Either way, the lookup isn't usable right now.
Beckett hasn't posted a new update since Oct 15. Its price guide, marketplace and BAS submissions are still waiting on undated later phases (Beckett Tech Updates).
This week's verification tip
Ask for photos of the paperwork before you drive. A collector wrote on October 20 about driving to a shop, running every COA number on his phone at the counter, and getting "not found" on all of them (dtcxp). His point: a cert that doesn't verify doesn't prove a fake, but it means nobody is vouching for the autograph. And because forgers copy real numbers, a match only counts if the record describes the item in front of you (dtcxp). Step by step: How to verify a COA.
Spotted an error? Reply or email hello@coaguide.com. Our corrections process is on the methods page.
We don't authenticate items. Educational info with sources only.
