Home / Flags & Fakes / Issue #3

Issue #3 · Oct 22, 2026

Flags & Fakes #3: Beckett's lookups are back, and what eBay's guarantee doesn't check

Welcome back to Flags & Fakes, the free weekly from COA Guide. We collect public, sourced information about autograph authenticators and Certificates of Authenticity. We don't authenticate items. Every claim below links to its source.

Beckett's cert lookups are back online

Last week we said Beckett was still dark. Since then, Beckett's October 15 Tech Update announced Phase 1 of its restoration: customer accounts, the Online Submission Center, population reports, and both BGS card grading and BAS autograph certificate lookup are available again (Beckett Tech Updates). That ended an outage of about 36 days (CardGrade).

Still waiting: the price guide, marketplace, and dealer portals (Phase 2), plus new Beckett Authentication Services submissions and app updates (Phase 3). Neither phase has a date (Beckett Tech Updates).

If you put a Beckett purchase on hold, now's the time to run the check and save a dated screenshot. Our updated guide has both official lookup addresses: Beckett lookup is back after outage.

Michigan AG sues a seller over undelivered signed helmets

Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel filed a consumer-protection lawsuit on October 8 against HailgateA2 LLC and its owner. Among the complaints, three consumers allege they paid for signed helmets from Michigan's 2025 national championship team and never received them (CBS Detroit). These are allegations in a civil case, not findings. The AG's first tip is to know your vendor before you pay (CBS Detroit).

Lookup status this week

Our automated check ran Oct 22, 2026, 6:44 AM PT (live tracker):

  • Responding: JSA, Upper Deck, MLB, Tristar, ACOA, SWAU, GOAT Authentics, Celebrity Authentics
  • Check blocked: Beckett, PSA and Fanatics (bot protection; not an outage signal). We confirmed Beckett's lookups by hand on Oct 17.
  • Not responding: OnlineAuthentics

"Responding" only means the page loaded. It doesn't mean results are correct.

This week's verification tip

eBay's Authenticity Guarantee checks the card, not the signature. eBay's trading card threshold dropped to $200 from $250 this summer (Card Capsule). But eBay's help page says the inspection "does not verify the authenticity of the autograph, patch or relic itself" (Card Capsule, quoting eBay). If the autograph is the reason you're paying, verify it separately: check the manufacturer's certification or a third-party cert on the authenticator's own site. Start here: How to verify a COA.


Spotted an error? Reply or email hello@coaguide.com. Our corrections process is on the methods page.

We don't authenticate items. Educational info with sources only.

Get Flags & Fakes by email

Subscribe on Beehiiv

Free weekly email. Unsubscribe anytime.

← Issue #2 Issue #4 →