Home / Flags & Fakes / Issue #2

Issue #2 · Oct 15, 2026

Flags & Fakes #2: Beckett still dark, and a forged-grade case hits sentencing

Welcome back to Flags & Fakes, the free weekly from COA Guide. We collect public, sourced information about autograph authenticators and Certificates of Authenticity. We don't authenticate items. Every claim below links to its source.

Beckett's lookup: still offline, no new date

Beckett's websites, app, and certificate lookup remain offline since September 9, 2026 (CardGrade). The last company update collectors are citing is still the October 2 note: suspicious technical activity during planned IT work, a forensic investigation, and a three-phase restoration plan with certificate lookup in Phase 1 (RippingPatrol). Beckett has not announced a return date (CardGrade).

If a purchase depends on a Beckett check you can't run yet, pause until you can, or use the workaround checklist in Beckett lookup is down: what to do now.

Forged PSA grades: cooperator avoids prison; Curcio sentencing set

On October 14, a Manhattan federal judge allowed a Washington state youth sports coach who admitted bankrolling a roughly $2 million Michael Jordan trading-card scam, and who testified against the main defendant, to avoid prison (Law360).

That case is the same SDNY prosecution in which a jury convicted Anthony Curcio in January for selling sports and Pokémon cards with forged PSA grades. Prosecutors said Curcio cleaned ratings and serial numbers off real PSA labels, then printed fake 9s and 10s and new cert numbers; co-defendant Iosif Bondarchuk pleaded guilty and was described as a front man (U.S. Attorney’s Office, SDNY). Curcio was arrested in Canada in late September, returned to U.S. custody in early October, and is now set for sentencing on November 18, 2026 (Inner City Press).

The collector takeaway: a sticker and a serial number are only as good as the record—and the label—behind them.

Lookup status this week

Our automated check ran Oct 15, 2026, 9:07 AM PT (live tracker):

  • Down: Beckett (known outage)
  • Responding: JSA, Upper Deck, MLB, Tristar, ACOA, SWAU, GOAT Authentics, Celebrity Authentics
  • Check blocked: PSA and Fanatics (bot protection; not an outage signal)
  • Not responding: OnlineAuthentics

"Responding" only means the page loaded. It doesn't mean results are correct.

This week's verification tip

Don't trust a number that can't be matched to the item. In the Curcio case, prosecutors said fake high grades were printed onto cleaned real PSA labels, then sold after buyers who caught the fraud got refunds (DOJ). When a lookup returns a photo or description, compare it to what you hold: signer or player, year, item type, grade, and where the label sits. Full walkthrough: How to verify a COA.


Spotted an error? Reply or email hello@coaguide.com. Our corrections process is on the methods page.

We don't authenticate items. Educational info with sources only.

Get Flags & Fakes by email

Subscribe on Beehiiv

Free weekly email. Unsubscribe anytime.

← Issue #1 Issue #3 →